Key Takeaways
- A medical billing audit is a process in which internal or external auditors systematically review claims to identify errors and ensure compliance.
- A medical billing audit is conducted to ensure claims and subsequent payments align, while a coding audit ensures that the code for a procedure or service is supported by the documentation.
- Audits are typically conducted annually, with a few exceptions for high-risk cases.
- An audit provides insights into the performance of a practice’s billing workflows and its susceptibility to billing and coding errors.
Medical practices, aside from delivering excellent patient care, aim to earn. Profitability and breaking even are two things that help them succeed in a saturated healthcare market. To do this, they use revenue cycle practices that help them maximize earnings while protecting their revenue cycle.
Given the unpredictability of the billing landscape and the risks of playing out in the open, practices are often exposed to classic triggers, such as sudden spikes in claim denials or operational bottlenecks like EHR migrations and annual CPT/HCPCS code updates, which can cause billing errors. This is where an expert medical billing audit can help.
What is a Medical Billing Audit
Whether to identify the current condition of the practice’s billing infrastructure or target points of improvement in different aspects of the same, the goal of a medical billing audit remains the same: to ensure that the billing system is up and running and that it complies with the enduring guidelines from bodies and institutions that safeguard billing and revenue cycle management.
Since the entire billing process generates revenue for the practice, an audit ensures nothing gets in the way. Its insights provide ways to minimize or eliminate roadblocks and triggers that stall or prevent the system from collecting payment. This is also why billing companies strive to achieve an almost-perfect clean-claim rate in their pre-submission audits, as it often means all the claims they processed passed the clearinghouse and are ready for processing.
A billing audit, however, differs from a coding audit. The latter is part of the broader billing audit process, where CPT and HCPCS codes are reviewed against documentation, specialty-specific coding requirements, and prior authorization.
Types of Medical Billing and Coding Audits
Internal vs. External
The difference lies in who conducted the audit. In an internal audit, the expected executors are the practice’s providers or staff. Large-scale practices such as hospitals and group practices may have their own auditing team within their billing department. An external audit, on the other hand, refers to an auditor or auditing firm outside the practice. External auditors and auditing service companies are perceived as more reliable because they are not affiliated with the practice.
Prospective vs. Retrospective
The difference lies in the audit timing. A prospective audit precedes claim submission. These audits are preferred by the Office of the Inspector General (OIG) and are best suited for high-risk areas previously identified in a few external audits. A retrospective audit, on the other hand, is done on claims that have been adjudicated. This is to identify any insights from the previous internal claims process and provide direction for any subsequent submissions.
Random vs. Focused
The difference lies in specificity. A random audit is generally preferred in prospective auditing, as it provides baseline information on the highlights and lowlights of billing health. Focused audits, on the other hand, target a specific metric or aspect of billing, such as E/M levels or modifier use, and can be conducted systematically by medical coding services.
Payer Audits
Payers often require external audits of their roster of providers. Auditing programs, such as Medicare MACs’ Targeted Probe and Educate (TPE) and the Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC), aim to educate providers about common billing errors and prevent improper payments from being recovered.
Signs Your Practice Needs an Audit
Rising Denials
A sudden spike in your denial rate could mean improper coding practices, medical necessity issues, or incorrect modifier application. These denials are categorized using different denial codes.
Flat Collections with Steady Volume
If you are seeing the same number of patients, your collection rate benchmarks must be proportionate. However, something may be wrong with your billing pipeline if it is stalling, perhaps due to aging A/R or denied claims.
E/M Distribution Far from Peers
Standing out from your specialty for the wrong reasons, such as undercoding or overcoding office visits, can be a red flag for your payer.
New Provider Onboarding
New doctors and providers are naturally getting the hang of your system, which includes your EHR and coding guidelines, making them prone to billing errors.
Payer Letters
Payers may send you correspondence regarding a planned audit, as they may have identified underlying issues with your claim submissions or to ensure periodic compliance.
How to Conduct a Medical Billing Audit
Set scope
Determine how you will conduct your audit. Will you audit internally or externally? Audit specifically because of an issue in one aspect that you want to target? Will you audit based on timing because you need insights into how the internal process works? Setting the scope also means setting the groundwork for the entire auditing process.
Pick sample
To cherry-pick a realistic batch of charts to audit, you can either pull a random sample of 15 to 30 claims from each provider if you are looking for baseline information about their compliance and potential for clean submission, or extract selected charts that you think have recurring ‘red flags’ identified during the first step.
Pull records
The chart itself is not enough to determine its compliance and profitability. You must cross-reference your charts with other documents, such as EHR documentation, the CMS-1500 form, clearinghouse scrubber remarks, and the ERA showing how the payer remits payment, all of which must comply with HIPAA standards.
Compare documentation to codes
We are not done cross-referencing yet. This time, we must complete our coding audit by comparing assigned codes against key paperwork, such as clinical notes and CPT/HCPCS and ICD-10 coding guidelines, to ensure coding assignments are accurately justified and aligned with strict coding standards.
Check claims and payments against contracts
The main cause of overpayment and underpayment is the provider not following the payer’s agreed-upon fee schedule. In this process, verify whether the payment indicated in your fee schedule is the same amount as what you receive from ERA.
Score and find patterns
Calculate your metrics, such as denial rates, after considering various discrepancies in your audit. Note recurring practices that could have caused these discrepancies. It could range from a billing staff member misapplying a specific modifier to A/Rs sitting for weeks.
Fix, re-educate, and re-audit
Implement corrective workflows by first fixing the recurring practices, re-educating the billing staff on the errors you identified in the audit, ensuring they do not repeat them, and conducting a follow-up audit after a few months to see whether the workflow works.
Medical Billing Audit Checklist
To turn the steps above into a practical guide for providers who are still confused about the billing audit process, we provide an audit checklist you can use or modify to match your auditing objectives and plans.
Front-end
- Have I ensured that the patient information matches the information on their insurance cards?
- Is their coverage active?
- Are prior authorization numbers ready to be cross-referenced against CPT code assignments?
- Are providers credentialed and assigned to a practice TIN?
Coding
- Do the provider’s clinical notes justify the procedure’s medical necessity?
- Are assigned E/M codes compliant with the Medical Decision Making (MDM) and documented time guidelines?
- Are modifiers compliant with the NCCI bundling rules?
- Are diagnosis-to-procedure codes aligned and specified accordingly?
Claims
- Does every completed patient encounter correspond to a submitted claim?
- Are the claims scrubbed after clearinghouse edits?
- Are the claims submitted within the prescribed payer window?
- Does each claim have the appropriate NPI assignment?
Payments
- Do the payments remitted match the payer’s fee schedule in the contract?
- Are balance transfers accounted for after adjudication?
- Are the contractual write-offs made distinct from the rest of the denial codes?
- Are refunds in place for duplicated or overpaid claims?
Denials
- Are aging A/Rs followed up on accordingly?
- Are denial codes from various physician billing mistakes categorized accordingly?
- Are valid denials appealed within the prescribed window?
Compliance
- Do BAAs and ePHI access comply with HIPAA regulations?
- Are CMS overpayments reported within 60 days?
- Are all audits, reviews, and logs contained in a centralized master file?
What to Do with Audit Findings
Audit findings are not just fine print that you complete out of mere compliance. They provide valuable insights into how you can improve performance and achieve your target billing metrics in the future. You can use these insights by correcting any errors you found during the audit, educating your billing staff on proper billing and coding practices, and establishing a workflow that prevents these recurring errors from happening again.
Overpayments, for instance, are common audit findings that can happen by accident. This means you must return the excess amount to the payer, and Medicaid and Medicare often have strict return policies in these situations. No matter how legally complex it is to return the excess amount, it is the right thing to do and can prevent trouble with payers in the future.
In-House vs. Outsourced Audits
| Aspects | In-House Audit | Outsourced Audit |
| Cost | Overhead cost, which covers salary, auditing software, and training | Quote-based, depending on the medical billing audit services needed and scale of practice |
| Objectivity | Lower, as internal auditing staff may overlook certain aspects of audit workflows | Higher, as external audits lean towards established compliance standards and long-standing auditing practices |
| Expertise | Practice-specific, as internal auditing staff is expected to be well-versed with their native EHR and practice audit workflows | Specialized and comprehensive, external auditors are expected to apply NCCI and CMS compliance standards in claims processing and payment reconciliation. |
FAQs
What is a medical billing audit?
A medical billing audit is a process in which internal or external auditors systematically review claims by cross-referencing several documentation and payment references to identify any billing errors and ensure compliance with institutional billing standards.
What are the types of medical audits?
There are different ways to conduct medical billing audits. They are grouped into sets: internal/external, prospective/retrospective, and random/focused. These sets vary based on the auditor’s involvement with the practice, timing, and level of specificity.
How often should a practice audit its billing?
A major audit must be conducted at least yearly, but it is recommended that practices conduct mini-audits every 90 days after a major audit to evaluate the level of improvement in the corrections made. Multiple audits, on the other hand, can be done for high-risk areas.
What is the difference between a billing audit and a coding audit?
The difference lies in the audit focus. A billing audit primarily checks payment alignment with prescribed fee schedules, while a coding audit ensures coding accuracy by linking the code to its documentation, clinical notes, and specific diagnosis code.
What happens if an audit finds overpayments?
An overpayment that originated from the payer, especially Medicare and Medicaid, must be returned within 60 days. Practices that experienced this must immediately fix it and educate their staff to report it promptly.
How much does a medical billing audit cost?
The cost varies by scope and sample. Most billing companies offer quote-based pricing to match your exact billing and auditing needs.
Final Thoughts
An audit is an essential part of the billing process because it ensures your workflows stay on track, payments meet your expectations, and errors are flagged before they cause major issues for your revenue cycle. To ensure it’s done right, you need to make bolder decisions, including choosing a billing company that can audit your claims on your behalf.
Contact Credex Healthcare to explore our billing and auditing services and discuss with our auditing specialists how they can help you maximize collections without compromising the steps.