Key Takeaways
- Coordination of benefits (COB) determines which insurance plan pays first and how much each plan owes when a patient carries more than one coverage.
- The birthday rule governs COB for dependent children: the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year has the primary plan.
- Medicare is secondary to employer group health plans when a beneficiary aged 65 or older has active coverage through an employer with 20 or more employees.
- Medicaid is the last payer to be billed. Bill every other payer first before submitting to Medicaid.
- CO-22 means another payer may cover the claim based on coordination of benefits rules. OA-23 means the payment reflects what the prior payer has already paid. Both can be fixed with the right documentation.
- Running insurance eligibility verification before every visit is the single most effective way to prevent COB denials before they happen.
One plan is the first to pay. That one hides what is left. But in multi-payer practices, COB is one of the most reliable ways to get claims reprocessing turned down. This is because the rules differ each plan type, payer, and patient, and the COB status of the same patient can change from year to year without anyone telling you.
This guide talks about how claims are processed, how COB works, the rules that decide payment order, and what to do when CO-22 and OA-23 show up in your AR.
What Is Coordination of Benefits?
Health insurance plans set up the payment order when a patient has more than one coverage through a process called “coordination of benefits.” The goal is simple: the total amount paid out by all plans shouldn’t be more than the actual amount of the claim. Neither plan wants to pay too much. They both need to know who starts.
The main plan pays out first. The backup plan pays after the primary plan has handled the claim. It does this by applying its own rules to any remaining amount.
Stuck With CO-22 and OA-23 Denials in Your AR?
Credex Healthcare works your COB denials, confirms the correct payer order and resubmits claims before timely filing runs out.
How COB Works Step by Step
The steps always happen in the same order. A rejection occurs when any step is incorrect.
Before the patient’s first visit, find out which plan is the most important. Most practices do this when they check whether you have insurance at the front desk. If a patient gives you two plans, check both and write the COB order in the patient’s chart.
Then send the main plan bill. Send a clean claim, wait for the explanation of benefits to show what was paid, and record the remaining balance.
Next, bill the second plan. Include the EOB for the primary plan, the amount paid, and the remaining balance due. The secondary plan handles its part according to its own rules.
You shouldn’t charge the patient for any extra money until both insurance plans are paid. It is risky to collect from a patient before both plans have been processed. It can also lead to denial.
Primary vs Secondary Insurance
The main plan pays out first. After, the second plan pays. The order is set by COB rules, not by which plan the patient wants, or which one has better benefits.
One thing that secondary does not mean is that it is a backup for costs that the primary denied because they were medical. The secondary plan uses its own rules for cost-sharing to handle the rest of a paid claim. A clinical rejection from the main plan doesn’t always go to the backup plan.
COB Rules: How Primary and Secondary Are Determined
Different rules apply depending on the patient’s situation. These are the scenarios practices encounter most.
The Birthday Rule (Dependent Children)
The birthday rule tells you which parent’s plan is primary when a child who lives with you is covered by both. The parent whose birthday falls first in the calendar year (not their birth year) has the most important plan. Have the same birthday? The plan that has been in place longer is the most important one.
This rule applies to business plans that follow the NAIC Coordination of Benefits Model Regulation, which most states have adopted. You can change these defaults through state law or your own plan’s contractual adjustment. Check with each plan directly to see if a child has dual coverage, as making assumptions can cost a lot of money.
Employee vs. Dependent Coverage
People who are covered by both an employer’s plan and a spouse’s plan as a dependent are covered by the employer’s plan first. It doesn’t matter which plan they’re listed as a dependent on. This is true no matter which plan has more benefits.
Active Coverage vs. COBRA or Retiree Coverage
People who have both an active employer plan and COBRA or retiree coverage should use the active employer plan. All the time. Active coverage comes first, so COBRA and retiree plans don’t compete with it.
Divorced or Separated Parents
When parents get divorced or split up, there is a set COB order for a kid who depends on them. The main plan is made by the parent who has legal custody. If that parent later remarries, the stepparent’s plan is less important. Third is the parent who doesn’t have custody.
None of this matters if the court orders one parent’s plan to be the main one. If there is a court order, it takes precedence over the above default rules.
Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) Rules
MSP rules say when Medicare has to pay first and when someone else has to. It costs a lot to get this wrong. CMS can get back overpayments, and they do.
Age 65 and employer coverage. Medicare comes after an employer group health plan (EGHP) if the beneficiary is covered by their own job or their spouse’s job, and the employer has 20 or more workers. With fewer than 20 workers, Medicare is the primary insurance plan.
Disability and employer coverage. For people under 65 who get Medicare because they are disabled, Medicare must be secondary if they have 100 or more employees. For employers with fewer than 100 workers, Medicare is the primary insurance plan.
End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD). Medicare comes second during a 30-month planning period that starts when someone is eligible for Medicare because they have ESRD. Medicare takes over after 30 months.
No-fault insurance and workers’ comp. Medicare is always less important than no-fault insurance and workers’ compensation when those are the only options for the claim.
Before billing Medicare for any of these types of patients, check their MSP status through the HIPAA Eligibility Transaction System (HETS) or directly with the insurance company.
Medicaid and TRICARE in COB
Medicaid. TRICARE and Medicaid are both part of COB Medicaid. Federal law says that Medicaid is the last payer. Any private plan, Medicare, or other insurance that pays for care must be paid and processed before Medicaid pays. It’s not just a risk to reject billing Medicaid first when another active payer exists. It’s about billing compliance.
TRICARE. Most of the time, other health insurance is more important than TRICARE. But Medicaid is an exception: if a person has both TRICARE and Medicaid, TRICARE takes precedence. When a patient has both TRICARE and another type of insurance, the other plan pays first, and then TRICARE pays.
CO-22 and OA-23 Denial Codes
These two codes appear together on COB-related claim denials, and they mean different things.
CO-22 means that the claim might be paid by another party; it is based on the insurer’s COB information. This code means that the plan that puts it up thinks that another plan should pay first. That’s not a final no. It is a request for proof of COB.
OA-23 shows that the payment has been changed to match what another payer has already paid for the claim. This is an update to the facts, not a rejection. It lets you know the secondary plan’s payment was made based on the primary plan’s EOB.
The PR-31 denial code means “Patient cannot be identified as our insured” under X12 claim adjustment reason codes.
How to Fix a CO-22 Denial
There are three ways to respond to a CO-22.
If the payer posting CO-22 is actually the main payer, get proof that the other coverage is either not current, is secondary, or has been canceled. Send in a new claim or an appeal with the new information attached.
Get the EOB from the primary plan and resubmit as a secondary claim if the payer posting CO-22 is correct. Enter the amount paid for the primary plan in field 29 of the CMS-1500 form or the equivalent section in the 837P loop.
If the patient no longer has the other coverage, make sure that both the patient and the other payer agree in writing that the coverage has ended. Write it down in the chart and send it again.
Timely filing windows are important here. People whose CO-22 denials are in the AR queue quickly lose their right to file an appeal. You have 30 days to work on them.
Preventing COB Denials: A Checklist for Front Desk and Billing Teams
You can avoid most COB rejections during booking and check-in. Before the claim goes out, these five steps catch most of the issues.
Check whether your insurance covers the visit before each one. Not just the first time you see them. When one spouse changes jobs, when a patient turns 65, or when COBRA coverage starts, the COB situation changes. By October, a patient who was checked out in January might have different coverage.
At every visit, ask about more than one type of coverage. Patients don’t always say that their condition has changed on their own. Most of the time, a straight question at check-in will catch them.
In both the chart and the payment system, write down the COB order. Note which plan is the main and backup one, as well as the user information for each one and the date it was checked.
When a patient reports a change, get information about the other plan. Please do not send until both plans have been checked and the COB order has been confirmed.
Check the Medicare MSP status of any patient who might have employer-sponsored coverage through HETS. Not only on the first visit, but before every treatment as well.
Conclusion
COB rejections can be avoided. A well-trained front desk and medical billing services can catch most COB problems before the claim goes out because the rules are always the same.
When CO-22 or OA-23 show up in your AR anyway, you can fix them as long as you file within the deadline. Most practices run into issues because people don’t know the rules. It checks them right away, at the point of care, before the claim is sent in.
Need help with denial codes in medical billing management or coordination-of-benefits workflows in your practice? Learn more about Credex Healthcare’s denial management services and insurance eligibility verification, or contact us for a free billing review.
Stop COB Denials Before the Claim Goes Out
Talk to our billing team for a free review of your eligibility checks, payer order and COB workflow.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is coordination of benefits in health insurance?
Insurance companies use a process called “coordination of benefits” to determine the best way to pay a customer with more than one health insurance plan so they don’t get paid twice. The main plan pays out first. After the primary plan pays, the secondary plan may cover some or all of the remaining balance.
How does the birthday rule work for COB?
The birthday rule is used when both parents’ plans cover a child who depends on them. The parent whose birthday falls first in the calendar year, by month and day (not birth year), has the primary plan. If both parents were born on the same day, the plan that has been in place the longest is the main one.
When is Medicare the secondary payer?
Medicare takes a back seat when a user aged 65 or older has an active group health plan through a company with 20 or more employees. For Medicare disability, you need at least 100 employees. Medicare is also secondary during the ESRD planning phase, which lasts for 30 months.
What does the CO-22 denial code mean?
Based on information about coordinating benefits, CO-22 means the payer believes another plan may be responsible for the claim. That’s not a final no. You can fix it by providing proof of which plan is primary or by resubmitting it as a secondary claim with the EOB for the primary plan attached.
Is Medicaid always the last payer?
Yes. Federal law says that Medicaid is the last payer. Commercial insurance, Medicare, and TRICARE must all be paid and the claim processed before Medicaid will pay. Billing Medicaid first is not only a denial risk when there is another active payer. It is also against the rules.
How do I prevent coordination of benefits denials?
Before every visit, check to see if the patient has insurance, ask about multiple coverages at check-in instead of just at intake, write down the COB order in the patient’s chart and the billing system, and use HETS to check the patient’s Medicare MSP status for patients who might have coverage through their workplace. Most COB rejections are caused by unreliable or out-of-date qualification information.